1608cc wrote: ↑Fri Jul 05, 2024 3:56 pm
On paper have the same dBi parameters. In real, couldn't say... I used to have half-wave dipole but only with few mW - coverage 100-200m only. The main reason I switched to j-pole is mounting position - it is straight and doesn't need much space around, so just screewed it to chimney without any boom.
The J-pole is more difficult to tune accurately, but the results are excellent when you get it right. It's interesting to compare the radiation shapes of the J-pole against the dipole. If the dipole is correctly fed (through a Pawsey Stub to make the output balanced), the results can be good, but in practice, you find that the upper arm of the dipole is responsible for most of the radiation, with the lower arm really just providing a counterpoise. Effectively, the dipole is radiating like a ¼-wave vertical that's matched.
The J-pole is working more like a ½-wave vertical, with a matching section below it. Theoretically, a ½-wave vertical has an infinite impedance at its feedpoint, so some kind of matching has to be done to bring down the feedpoint impedance to 50Ω. The lower third of the aerial is that matching section. The reason that the J-pole seems to give a better signal at distance is because the radiation pattern - if it's correctly matched - is like a flat doughnut, with little energy going upwards or downwards. You also have the advantage that the radiating part is a full ½-wave long.
Practical experience shows that more metal in the air usually means a better signal!
The convenience of the vertical J-pole also wins over a dipole - it's
much easier to mount, and doesn't suffer from needing a boom (the number of dipoles I've seen on bent poles is huge!).
The old NRG Halfwave vertical worked well too. The extremely high feedpoint impedance of the radiator is transformed by the coils and capacitor matching section under the cowl. The problem with the aerial is that the capacitor would flashover in damp air when trying to run higher power throught the thing!
My favourite aerial is the slotted colinear. I've built them with as much as 10dB of real gain (100 Watts in gives an ERP of 1 kW!). It's a hell of a lot of metal in the air, and they're huge, but it's often the cheapest power amplification method!